What You Think Marketing Is vs. What Marketing Actually Is
Updated: 6 days ago
Marketing 101, Part One
"I tried marketing. It didn't work."
I hear this constantly. And almost every time, when I ask what they actually did, the answer is one of two things: they did sales and called it marketing, or they did decoration and called it marketing.
Neither one is marketing. No wonder it didn't work.
Sales, in one line
Sales is one person, one conversation, one transaction.
The regular you text when the short rib special lands. The customer you walk back to the fitting room with three things she didn't ask for. The follow-up call. The "so what would it take to get you to yes."
Sales is honorable, skilled work. It's just not marketing.
Marketing, in one line
Marketing is four decisions: what you sell, what you charge, where people can get it, and what you say about it.
That's it. That's the whole thing.
Restaurant version: Adding a $14 lunch prix fixe is marketing. Pricing it at $14 instead of $11 is marketing. Deciding you're on DoorDash but not Uber Eats, and that the patio is open at 11 — marketing. The chalkboard out front is marketing.
Boutique version: Which brands you carry is marketing. Whether you're the $60 dress store or the $180 dress store is marketing. Online, in-store, or the pop-up at the fall festival — marketing. The window display is marketing.
Here's the problem: most people think marketing is only that last one. The sign. The post. The pretty stuff.
That's a quarter of the job. And it's the quarter that can't save you if the other three are wrong. No chalkboard on earth sells a mediocre menu at the wrong price in the wrong part of town.
The big one: outbound is sales
Cold emails. Cold calls. DMs. Walking a stack of catering menus into the office park. Texting your customer list a "hey, we miss you!"
All sales. Every bit of it.
I know it feels like marketing — it's proactive, it's at volume, you're writing words to get attention. But it's aimed at named individuals, one at a time, to get a sale this week. And it stops dead the second you stop doing it.
Marketing is built for a group of people, and it keeps working when you're not in the room. The reputation you build this year still sells for you in three years.
One's a faucet. One's a well. You need water either way — but only one of them works when the power's out.
Other things that aren't marketing
Your logo and colors. That's visual identity. Brand is what people say about you when you're not there.
Posting on Instagram. If you can't say who it was for and what you wanted them to do — that's not marketing, that's journaling in public.
Going to networking meetings. That's referral sales. Valuable. Not marketing. (Yes, I'm in that room too. I know what I'm doing in there.)
Running an ad. One promotion tactic. An ad without a strategy behind it is just money on fire in a nicer font.
A website refresh. New photos? Decoration. New offer, new pricing, new proof? Now we're talking.
Why nobody explains this to you
Because confusion is profitable. If you don't know what marketing is, you can't tell whether you're getting it — and you can't ask why you're paying monthly for twelve social posts and a "brand refresh."
Marketing isn't hard to understand. It's hard to do well. Those are different problems, and only one of them requires a retainer.
The three-question test
Before you call something marketing, ask:
Was this built for a group of people, or aimed at one named person?
Does it keep working when I'm not there?
Did it change what I sell, what I charge, or where people can buy it — or did it only change how loudly I talked?
Try this
Write down everything you did last week that you'd call marketing. Run each one through the three questions.
Whatever survives is your marketing program. If the page comes out blank — that's not a failure. That's a diagnosis. Now you know what to build.
Did your list come up short?
That's not a failure - that is a starting point. I do marketing diagnostics: I look at all four decisions, tell you which ones are actually broken, and give you the fix in priority order. $450, creditable toward anything we do next.
Book a free 20-minute call and I'll tell you straight whether you need it.
Next in the series: What Is Digital Marketing? Short version — it's not a separate thing. It's the same four decisions, on a screen. Somebody built an entire industry convincing you otherwise.
Comments